Related Subjects: Author Index Reviews Page 1 2
Book reviews for "Totman,_Conrad" sorted by average review score:

Tokugawa Ieyasu: Shogun
Published in Paperback by Heian Intl Pub Co (1988)
Author: Conrad Totman
Amazon base price: $10.36
List price: $12.95 (that's 20% off!)
Used price: $7.94
Collectible price: $10.47
Buy one from zShops for: $9.24
Average review score:

What are you looking for?
If you are looking for a readable bio of Tokugawa Ieyasu in English, you have found one in Totman's. However, this is a rather lightweight historical work. Much of it was copied from a Japanese text, and the author admits this. Unfortunately, pickings on Tokugawa in English are slim. General works on Japan's 16th century are better. I recommend Boxer's The Christian Century in Japan, Elison's collection Warlords, Artists, and Commoners, and Sansom's A History of Japan: 1334-1615. They give a clearer picture of the times.

Written with Sympathy - good and easy read
This book is a biography of one of the most interesting men in history of Japan and the whole mankind. Tokugawa Ieyasu created the order which outlasted him for several generations and which in its stability was something so many talented warriors and politicians (due to the character of age in question - Sengoku Jidai - everyone had to be a little bit of both) aimed at, but did not succeed.

This books explores many very interesting and important subjects in realities of that age such as "marriage politics", means of securing peace with neighbours (such as, among others, exchange with hostages) and some military campaigns. But most of all, the book concentrates on one subject which is the personality of this extraordinary individual. As the author states in Acknowledgements, the book was not intended to be a definitive scholarly study and it is based on one source only - Ieyasuden by Professor Nakamura, the authority on this subject.

This book is very good as a stand-alone reading and to read in conjunction with other books on this subject (e.g., books by Stephen Turnbull for military aspects and Campbridge history of Japan for socio-economic depth).

A Great Read about a Great Man
Tokugawa Ieyasu was probably one of the world's great leaders. He was patient and brilliant. He waited for just the right moment to make his move and unify Japan under his Shogunate. Unfortunately little is availible about this great man in English. Clavell's Shogun is a masterpiece based on Ieyasu's life, but ultimately fiction. Totman's book is a rare English biography of Ieyasu. And Totman wrote an excellent and highly readable account of Ieyasu's life.


Japan Before Perry
Published in Paperback by University of California Press (1982)
Author: Conrad Totman
Amazon base price: $19.95
Used price: $4.95
Average review score:

A summary of pre-modern japan
This book covers the history of Japan in an enthusiastic way from its early histories with the Joman dolls up to the blackships of commodore Perry. I first read this in my Japanese history course, we were required to read parts of the book as a backbone for the lectures, but soon i found that I was reading the entire book. It's actually quite a easy read and Japan's history is quite refreshing for someone who's been embraced in european histories all his life. Chapters about the Heian and warring states period (in the 16th century) are the most interesting and helpful.


A History of Japan (Histories of the World)
Published in Hardcover by Blackwell Publishers (1900)
Author: Conrad D. Totman
Amazon base price: $70.95
Average review score:

Interesting approach, chaotic results
Totman tries ever-so-hard to liberate his history from traditionalist binaries such as East vs. West and industrial vs. pre-industrial. He does this by examining history from an ecological perspective, examining the interaction between man and the environment. At first, this approach seems to work remarkably well. It is possible, it seems, to deduce pre-historic settlement patterns from the environmental record alone.

Yet, the novelty of his approach begins to break down when he tries to fit all of Japanese history into four distinct stages defined by the ability of the society to extract and process resources (e.g. crops, minerals, forests, etc.). This is just old-style development theory dressed in a new suit. Also, Totman conveniently abandons the ecological model when examining such items as culture, even though he vainly tells the reader that he has not forgotten his approach! When the author has to remind the reader that he hasn't strayed from his theme, it's a sure sign that he has!

The result of all this is a highly fragmented account that is difficult to read without prior knowledge of Japanese history. If I were a professor in this field, it would be an agonizing decision to go back to Sansom's venerable 1960's volume instead of turning to the current scholarship used in Totman. And yet, Totman's book is so difficult to digest that it would probably be worth it.

Close, yet so far.
Although compact and covering a broad range of subjects, Totman's book carries with it several key flaws which a person should be aware of.

First, the almost complete reliance upon English sources. A quick browse through citations and quotes reveals rather quickly that virtually no Japanese sources have been used (if any) in the making of this book. This doesn't make the book "bad" or one sided so much as it makes it woefully incomplete. Many of the English language sources cited are from around 1997, which makes them very recent, but one further problem lingers. That is, the sources for Totman's sources. Generally speaking research on Japan is generally speaking 20 years behind research in the US. New "breakthroughs" by US researchers don't get much press in Japan simply because the "breakthrough" is already common knowledge by the time it gets here. As result, although the views expressed in the book reflect new thinking in American or European circles they do not neccisarily reflect those in Japan at the present.

Another "flaw", although not as fatal as the one listed above, is the division he seems to employ in (or rather impose upon) Japanese history. This is an old argument (in Japan, anyway), but deserves attention. The book is divided up into 4 major parts: prehistory (Japan up until the Nara period), Classical (Nara-Heian), Medieval (Kamakura-Edo), and Modern (Meiji- ). The modern era is then devided into pre and post-war Japan. The Major problem here comes in this heavy-handed lumping of eras based upon the European version of (European) history. For perhaps the past two or three decades in Japan the validity of this lumping has been debated and challenged, which has led to the breaking down of paradigms associated with the "classical" age or the "medieval" age. What this in effect did inside Totman's work was create an oversimplification of areas of history which deserve far more attention (for example the Kamakura period hardly gets notice, and the split in to the Northern and Southern Courts and the subsequent 70 years of war, are virtually ignored). This, I fear, is a fairly typical bias seen in Western writing regarding Japanese history, with only Sansom breaking the mold over 40 years ago.

To meantion this books strengths, it gives quickly and easily (although at times oversimplified) readable views of the many aspects of Japanese political, cultural, and societal history, and takes a slightly different stance on modern Japanese history which begins to reflect the views developed in Japan by people such as Ito Takashi. A more candid view based on factual rather than ideological of Japanese history on the whole can be seen emerging, however the shortened pen with which things are written can lead to misundertanding of facts and events.

This volume will serve as a good general guide to Japanese history on the whole, but is oversimplified in many important areas. This book may, however, serve as a good springboard in to more detailed histories, such as Cambridge's or Sansoms, and may even serve in the reverse to give new insight into the problems sighted in these older works.

An outstanding history.
Conrad Totman's A History Of Japan conceptualizes four major "ages" grounded in the material resources that sustained Japanese society: the age of foragers, dispersed agriculturalists, intensive agriculture, and industrialism. Totman beings with Stone Age society in Japan, and then moves through developments in agriculture, state-building, the blossoming of classical arts and letters, socioeconomic growth and change, domestic and diplomatic politics, social issues of class, gender and ethnicity, cultural production and the environmental effects of agricultural activity. A History Of Japan provides detailed coverage of the twentieth century when Japan grew into a much larger society and its role on the international science became militarily, economically, and culturally influential. A History Of Japan is a highly recommended, informative, scholarly, comprehensive, and "reader friendly" introduction and historical survey that will be much appreciated by students of Japanese history and culture, and has a wealth of material for the non-specialist general reader seeking to understand the Japan of antiquity as well as a contemporary and influential society.


The Collapse of the Tokugawa Bakufu, 1862-1868
Published in Hardcover by University of Hawaii Press (1990)
Author: Conrad Totman
Amazon base price: $25.00
Used price: $55.00
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Early Modern Japan
Published in Paperback by University of California Press (1995)
Author: Conrad Totman
Amazon base price: $24.95
Used price: $12.69
Buy one from zShops for: $19.96
Average review score:
No reviews found.

The Green Archipelago: Forestry in Preindustrial Japan
Published in Hardcover by University of California Press (1989)
Author: Conrad Totman
Amazon base price: $55.00
Used price: $45.00
Average review score:
No reviews found.

The Lumber Industry in Early Modern Japan
Published in Hardcover by University of Hawaii Press (1995)
Author: Conrad Totman
Amazon base price: $12.00
List price: $24.00 (that's 50% off!)
Used price: $8.99
Buy one from zShops for: $14.98
Average review score:
No reviews found.

The Origins of Japan's Modern Forests: The Case of Akita (Asian Studies at Hawaii, No 31)
Published in Paperback by University of Hawaii Press (1985)
Author: Conrad Totman
Amazon base price: $7.00
Used price: $10.59
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Politics in the Tokugawa Bakufu, 1600-1843
Published in Textbook Binding by Harvard Univ Pr (1967)
Author: Conrad D. Totman
Amazon base price: $17.50
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Tokugawa Japan
Published in Paperback by Univ of Tokyo Press (1992)
Authors: Conrad Totman, Shinsaburo Oishi, and Chie Nakane
Amazon base price: $55.25
Collectible price: $45.00
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Related Subjects: Author Index Reviews Page 1 2

Reviews are from readers at Amazon.com. To add a review, follow the Amazon buy link above.