Related Subjects: Author Index
Book reviews for "Stripp,_Alan" sorted by average review score:

The Man Who Never Was (Oxford Paperbacks)
Published in Paperback by Oxford University Press (1996)
Authors: Ewen Montagu and Alan Stripp
Amazon base price: $10.95
Used price: $2.07
Buy one from zShops for: $2.07
Average review score:

First hand account of a brilliant espionage campaign
Modern novellists would never have thought of this simple yet highly complicated plan to deceive the Germans during World War II. This book is written by Ewen Montagu who actually undertook the whole operation. Due to the fact of its high secrecy it could not first be revealed until the Mid-1950's when the first edition came out. Even then the full story could not be told for one of the other great secrets of WWII (the fact that the British had cracked the German code 'Engima') meant that the progress of the deception was monitored throughout its progress.

The deception was simple - dump a body with highly secret documents in a place where the Germans will be party to the find. Make it so convincing that they will take the bait. This was to mislead the Germans over the true place where the allies wanted to land (Sicily) so getting them to fortify another part of South Eastern Europe instead - the Dodecanese and Sardinia. It was a plan to save lives - as many allied lives as possible by reducing German resistance. And it worked - beautifully.

This book by Montagu gives us the absolute inside story with all the twists and turns to how the idea was conceived and how it was implemented. And for such a simple idea it was of course relatively complicated to implement. How to find an appropriately dead body to dump - where to dump it - how to make sure the Germans would find it without being suspicious of the material and so on. All very fascinating stuff and makes for a good, quick and easy read - it is very well-written and if nothing else is such an amazing story it is hard to put down.

This story is well publicised now - it has been the subject of at least one film and one documentary in the "Secrets of World War II" series, however it is nothing like information straight from the horses mouth to make you appreciate what it was all about.

My conclusion - Relatively short book but highly readable and very well worthwhile picking up even if your interest isn't in the arena of either War or World War II.

Famous case
This case is very famous. I remember reading about it in a declassified article in a Swedish book meant to teach intelligence to students of journalism at Lund University.

Great, and True, Espionage Story...
"The Man Who Never Was" is an interesting and true story of WWII espionage prior to the invasion of Sicily. I bought the book after seeing a History Channel episode of the topic, and I'm glad I did.

The story is best told by Ewen Montagu, the intelligence officer behind what is known as "Operation Mincemeat". His vantage point is ideal for telling this tale. His access to the how the operation developed, the people, side-stories, funny happenings, the actual letters, and all the other details could be no better provided by anyone else. What makes the story interesting for me is not only the details, but how Ewen was able to put himself in the shoes of the Germans, and through all the details, orchestrate a diversion of German forces from Sicily. The book also offers concrete details of the real effect of the operation obtained from German archives after the war. Such total first hand information is the making of a quality history book, and this is a first-class telling of an interesting operation. If you like WWII, spy stories, or history, then this a good read.


Codebreakers: The Inside Story of Bletchley Park
Published in Hardcover by Oxford University Press (1993)
Authors: Alan Stripp and Francis H. Hinsley
Amazon base price: $30.00
Used price: $34.50
Average review score:

Not really what I'd expected
When I purchased this book I expected a coherent study of what Bletchley Park was like during its WWII heyday. I knew that its contents were derived from the collected input of a number of people who were at Bletchley at that time. It is actually a collection of short essays by these people. Each has a slightly different theme and focus. Some of the essay were quite interesting, but over all, I did not come away with any kind of coherent understanding of how Bletchley Park operated, what it was like to work there, etc. I wish there had been an over-arching narrative to tie the pieces together.

Lots of good info; some topics missing
This book is a set of essays by people who actually worked at Bletchley Park during World War II, and describes in some detail what they did. Much of it is dry reading. That's because real cryptology is mostly dry work; months of boredom interrupted by moments of joy or chagrin. For those who care about World War II cryptology this is a "must read," but read either the 1967 or the 1996 edition of David Kahn's "The Codebreakers" first; otherwise, some of this book won't make much sense, for lack of context.

Some of the most interesting work done at Bletchley Park, and some of the most valuable people who worked there, are not mentioned at all in this book; not even a hint. I assume this is because of two problems: the British Official Secrets Act presumably still applies to a good deal of what happened at Bletchley Park, and the topics of inquiry that involved both British and American personnel could hardly be described in detail without the agreement of NSA, which might be hard to come by in some cases. I wish that two friends of mine who worked at Bletchley Park had been able to write memoirs of their work and their interactions with colleagues. But that didn't happen. However, we can hope that the remaining veil of official silence will be lifted some day.

The Old Vets Gather for a Last Hurrah
When the gag order was finally lifted circa 1970 on the Bletchley Park operations, a lot of scientific, historical, and technical histories appeared. And there was a great hue and cry among military and political historians that the whole history of the British and American war against Hitlerian Germany would have to be rewritten. Well, much of that has been proven to be just hyperbole but it is generally agreed that the war was shortened by about two years. But the closer the Allies got to Germany the less role Bletchley played for the German forces used landlines for most strategic communications from mid 1944 on. Also they had another machine known as FISH which was not as easily read as Enigma. This book is a collection of personal narratives of life at Bletchley and how tedious most of the work there was, no matter how essential. Harry Hinsley, one of the authors, was a "whiz kid" recruited directly from university and after the war became a professor without ever completing his studies. Over the years he has written the monumental multivolume official history of British intelligence operations in WW II and many historical papers. Alan Stripp, was one of the original operatives and served for many years.


Codebreaker in the Far East
Published in Paperback by Oxford University Press (2002)
Authors: Alan Stripp and Christopher Andrew
Amazon base price: $11.17
List price: $15.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $10.95
Buy one from zShops for: $8.98
Average review score:

Fine Narrative
The author was a cryptographer working out of Australia during WWW II. This is his personal narrative and an operational history combined. Not definitive because at the time of writing much documentation remained to be declassified. A worthwhile addition to a SIGINT collection.


Related Subjects: Author Index

Reviews are from readers at Amazon.com. To add a review, follow the Amazon buy link above.