Used price: $2.22
Collectible price: $7.41
Buy one from zShops for: $7.45
Used price: $25.00
Buy one from zShops for: $29.57
List price: $29.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $16.80
Buy one from zShops for: $19.71
Used price: $11.99
Buy one from zShops for: $12.89
Collins has written some great crime thrillers. I wish that his "Quarry" series, about an amoral hit-man, were back in print. Currently, those books are fetching some very high prices, but that's as it should be, because they contain some wonderfully tough and gritty writing. His comics work is of a high caliber as well: his character Ms Tree comes to mind, but there have been many others.
However, the movie and book of ROAD TO PERDITION are two very different animals. The graphic novel is much more of a true-crime actioner, with plenty of shootouts and long silences, where the pictures are allowed to carry the story without many word-balloons or captions. In his intro, Collins describes how the book was inpired by the extremely popular Japanese comics series, LONE WOLF AND CUB (which also was adapted to a movie, "Shogun Assassin"). It's apparent: anyone who has read LONE WOLF will recognize many similarities in the telling of the tale.
Ultimately, the movie (directed by Sam Mendes) does a better job with the framework of the story, deepening the relationship between the two main characters: a young boy and his enforcer father, who have to go on the lam to save themselves, when the father's crime-lord boss murders their family.
While Rayner's pictures are wonderfully evocative of the 1930s Al Capone era, the graphic novel may disappoint those who may have been fans of the movie, and who seek to further their knowledge of the characters. Still, it's a very fast read, and an enjoyable one.
The movie evades PERDITION's theme: reality of mortal sin and damnation over against HOPE FOR REDEMPTION. Mendes--who directed Yuppie New Age Classic, American Beauty--was perhaps incapable of more than meretriciously glossing what is a complex study of evil. The fact the film ignores featured roles of archetypal figures Al Capone,Frank Nitti; Eliot Ness & The Untouchables will suprise viewers who enjoyed the film but sensed something was missing. The Jude Law/Dutch Shultz character(in the film)is typical of Hannibal Lecter psychopaths who are allowed to preen in "glamour of evil" as if conscienceless embrace of EVIL were admirable. In the graphic novel, Law's character is nameless and appears on a single page(297). Theology and iconography of Roman Catholicsm (definitively nuanced, pre-1960's middle-class mid-Western Irish sensibility)defines THE ROAD TO PERDITION as quest of a Good man choosing EVIL to protect those he loves from this Evil. "GREATER LOVE HAS NO MAN THAN ONE WHO WILL YIELD HIS VERY SOUL FOR THE SAKE OF THOSE HE LOVES"? "The movie ROAD does not dare radical Christian paradoxes evoked in this "comic" book.(A horrendous movie "novelization"--aegised by Warner Bros--is to be avoided under pain of eternal perdition). Max Allan Collins graphic novel(accompanied by starkly realistic, black and white photo-GRAPHIC art work of Richard Piers Rayner, which some reviewers condemn as too minimalist)is mythic morality fable that will startle readers with its literary "gravitas" and its gripping gangbuster epic action...
Michael O'Sullivan is a man conscious of morality, though he is not a good man. His "business," which he does because he's expert with a rifle and because his boss raised him like a son, is kept separate from his normal life, in which he's a loving, churchgoing husband and father of two boys. The boys are curious about his life outside of home, so one day the oldest son tags along on a mob hit - and endangers the family.
The book, based upon the Japanese "Lone Wolf and Cub" series, is gorgeous to look at - the art really looks like old newspaper photos of actual crime scenes. This gives the work an authentic feel that evokes the period and is incredibly haunting.
The book's plot goes differently in some ways from the film's, and the book is actually better than the film. Michael is never portrayed as a soft man - even as he saves his son. The son is soon drawn into the world of killing people, unlike the son in the film, and has to save his father many times.
The ending of the book, which is different from the movie's ending and which I won't give away here, is a nice, ironic touch.
This is one thought-provoking, consistently interesting piece of art.
Used price: $1.90
Collectible price: $6.31
Buy one from zShops for: $2.16
One of the things that I liked most about this book was that there were not really any GOOD characters. They've all done something bad some time or another. It's about time a story didn't have a perfect character who saves the day all of the time.
If anyone wants a riveting murder mystery that actually makes some sense, and is surprisingly complex, then I'd say that "Murder Book" would be the best choice.
Used price: $0.86
Collectible price: $1.85
Buy one from zShops for: $10.99
Used price: $0.58
Collectible price: $1.07
Buy one from zShops for: $1.10
I think I love you after all. I suddenly don't love you. I don't really know you but I'll hire you. Get away from me, no, let's work together. I trust you, no, I want to destroy you.
Many characters are stick figures whose actions cannot be explained other than they help move the story along. I believe a good story is driven by characters, in The Cloud Sketcher, the characters exist to move along the the plot outline. Certain type of readers, such as myself, will still be unable to resist The Cloud Sketcher (architects, Finns, Jazz Age fans) but others will be quickly discouraged by characters acting out of... well, character.
This book is a passionate love story that begins in the back woods of Northern Finland in the early 1900's and continues through the Finnish Civil War. It ends in New York during the twenties.
What intrigues me most about this book is that it captures a time and a place about which I knew very little. It's got everything: a wonderful love story, history, politics, architecture and murder and it's all interwoven in a very compelling way. I could not put this book down.
To me, "The Cloud Sketcher" delivers what I expect from great literature. I highly recommend it to all who appreciate beautiful writing, a riveting story, and a unique journey into an incredibly vivid world.
List price: $13.00 (that's 20% off!)
All in all though, worth the read.
Used price: $5.25
Collectible price: $6.35
Used price: $3.50
Collectible price: $8.47
Buy one from zShops for: $9.98
don't waste your time...