Related Subjects: Author Index
Book reviews for "Povich,_Shirley" sorted by average review score:

Walter Johnson: Baseball's Big Train
Published in Paperback by Univ of Nebraska Pr (1998)
Authors: Henry W. Thomas and Shirley Povich
Amazon base price: $15.75
List price: $22.50 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $15.64
Buy one from zShops for: $15.59
Average review score:

Big Train is a well written account of a baseball "good guy"
If you have some time, and enjoy reading about one of baseball's best eras, then I strongly recommend this book. Henry Thomas has written a meticulously researched, 400 page account of the life of Walter Johnson. Not only does it expound upon his on-field brilliance, but it demonstrates the love and respect that everyone associated with baseball had for Walter. The foreword is written by longtime Washington sportswriter, Shirley Povich, and the book contains many fine photos. If you are not a baseball fan, the wordy and intricate game descriptions may be tiresome. But if you enjoy the game, you will enjoy this book.

You can't help not liking the Big Train
Henry Thomas seems to have inherited the Big Train's genes. One gentleman does a big service to another (his grandfather)as Walter johnson is depicted in this well researched and written biography. If you are an avid fan of great pitchers, dead-ball era ballplayers, or just enjoy a heartwarming story of a well respected gentleman baseball player, this book will not disappoint. Walter "Barney" Johnson was more than just the second winningest major league pitcher of all time with a blazing fastball. First and foremost he was the sports main ambassador of goodwill as well as the idol of Washington Senator fans and the entire baseball community. The only matter that the book did not clear up with me was how he derived the nickname "Big Train." In other aspects, the book was extremely well done.

What a pitcher! What a book!
One of the best baseball books I have ever read- easily on my top ten list and maybe even in my top five. I was not aware that the book was written by Johnson's great grandson until I began reading; this certainly gave the material a lot of credibility.
Walter Johnson was, without question, the greatest pitcher in baseball history. Along with Al Stump's work on Ty Cobb, Robert Creamer's work on Casey Stengel, and the recently published Cy Young biography (author's name escapes me), this book establishes a lasting legacy of Johnson on and off the field.


Redskins: A History of Washington's Team
Published in Paperback by Washington Post Books (1997)
Authors: Noel Epstein, Washington Post, Thomas Boswell, Anthony Cotton, Ken Denlinger, William Gildea, Thomas Heath, Richard Justice, Tony Kornheiser, and Shirley Povich
Amazon base price: $15.95
Used price: $6.49
Collectible price: $10.59
Average review score:

A great idea, careless and unprofessional execution
As a die hard Redskins fan, I was very sorry to see this excellent concept so badly muffed. The idea behind this book is to cash in on the Washington Post vault, providing great photos and articles combined with new pieces by long-time Skins beat reporters to tie it all together. Sadly, whoever edited and proofread this thing reeeally dropped the ball. Sentences at the bottom of the page are repeated at the top of the next, photographs are mislabeled, pieces of sentences are missing, words are chopped off in the middle. Probably still of some value for the die hard Skins fan, but a real black eye for the Washington Post. If their newspaper were produced as shoddily, Richard Nixon would have finished his second term.

not as bad as advertised
Yes, there are some typos and such in the early chapters but the book isn't as lousy as described in the 2-star review. Most of the problems are hyphen-ated words that are not at the end of a page or line. It is like the typeset was changed but the book was not reproofed.

Still, there is a lot of good information in the book. I think it covers items that Loverro's book (very good as well) ignored or glossed over-- how Gibbs wanted to sign and trade Riggo and how Joe Jacoby ended up sticking around in that first camp. The Times summary makes it sound like Gibbs and Beathard were geniuses building a team. This book shows that they were also lucky geniuses. If you are a Skins fan, you should own this book.

I see there is also a newer edition out with the Synder years (ugh).


The New Updated Edition Redskins: A History of Washington's Team
Published in Paperback by Washington Post Books (01 October, 2000)
Authors: Noel Epstein, Thomas Boswell, Liz Clarke, Anthony Cotton, Ken Denlinger, William Gildea, Richard Justice, Tony Kornheiser, Mark Maske, and Shirley Povich
Amazon base price: $15.95
Used price: $9.49
Buy one from zShops for: $12.95
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Related Subjects: Author Index

Reviews are from readers at Amazon.com. To add a review, follow the Amazon buy link above.