List price: $25.00 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $14.00
Collectible price: $13.72
Buy one from zShops for: $12.48
Used price: $16.59
Used price: $87.24
List price: $14.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $1.55
Collectible price: $9.90
Buy one from zShops for: $4.95
On the surface the story of a village's dissolution after a disease kills only the women is a dark, gothic and relentless tale of loss and suffering. It is also shows the weakening of the influence of the Roman Catholic Church, the increasing urbanization of Ireland and numerous human follies. During Father McGreevy's relentless deposition the reader sees that in spite of his earnest, if sometimes naive, efforts the village is going to fail. The reader knows that the good Father has been defrocked and that something disastrous has happened to the village but the novel details his futile efforts to prevent what the reader knows is inevitable. There are signs early in the novel that indicate Father McGreevy's power is not as great as one might think. For instance, there is a reference to an event years earlier involving the IRA when Father McGreevy is told not to interfere in what turns out to be the execution of a captured English army officer. How could a Christian man especially a priest turn his back on such an atrocity? This incident also brings to mind his attitude towards the English. During the Battle of Britain Father McGreevy and the other residents want the English to win but don't mind seeing them get their noses bloodied a little in the process. Did they not think that innocent men, women and children were dying in the process?
The story is relentless, tragic and well written. However, there are some flaws. There are noticeable anachronisms in Father McGreevy's accounts of the war. There are also anachronisms in the footnotes which were supposed to be written in the 50s but often reflect present day terminology or cite death dates for Irish artists who were alive beyond the 60s. All in all, it's entertaining and thought provoking although I fail to see why it was a Booker nominee.
Used price: $0.72
Collectible price: $3.55
Buy one from zShops for: $10.00
However, O'Doherty waxes much too purple for my taste when he lapses into streams of consciousness that seem to turn into whirlpools from which he cannot extricate himself. More unfortunately, while he has done tons of research on the details of say, seventeenth century Viennese table legs, he hasn't read too many diaries from the time. His prose seems awfully Victorian to me. Or pseudo-Victorian. Actually, there were times when it reminded me for all the world of Elinor Glyn.
His problem is that the novel isn't a seventeenth century form, and stream of consciousness, moreover, is a twentieth century construction. Still more incongruously, O'Doherty appears to have his eye on eighteenth century fictive diary prose such as Charlotte Bronte writes in Jane Eyre. However, he can't even separate the first person narrative of early novels from the stream of consciousness that readers today are familiar with. In addition, he uses three-point narration (Mlle. P., her father, and Anton Mesmer) and seems to be trying to do something along the lines of The Moonstone, yet another form that didn't exist in the seventeenth century. O'Doherty has set himself up for massive leaps of invention. Sadly, he never quite does what he sets out to do, and the thing shrivels in the bud.
I'm just addressing his prose style, though. If you can stomach it, then you have the pleasure of the devices he uses to work Mesmer, Mozart, Benjamin Franklin, Empress Maria Theresa, and most of the rest of the Hapsburg court, plus the French Revolution into 240 pages. They are actually pretty artful. So if you like that kind of stuff, and aren't fussy about the mode of communication, this might the book for you.
On top of that, there's sex, lots of it, and a blind girl Mesmer is trying to cure, and some neat messages about talent vs. function.
However, if you read for style and rhythm of language as much as plot, this will set your teeth on edge.
This novel may be technically out of print, but you can still buy it in many bookstores...There are probably lots of warehoused copies. Since it's on the Booker shortlist, there's a good chance it'll come back into print. Nonetheless, if you're interested, you ought to grab it while you can.
While there are horrific moments highlighting the destructive effects of ill-conceived parental control, O'Doherty sheds light on the mysterious penchant talented people have for falling into the hands of suppressive creeps. The doctor seems sincere enough, but even he cannot keep his hands off the lovely musician.
Chapters told by different characters, the story is a fine exercise in viewpoint and voice. O'Doherty sets his scenes with amazing conservation of adjectives. The language and syntax alone paints vivid pictures of court settings. This reader really got the impression O'Doherty did his research meticulously.
Now that the author's shortlisted for the Booker, we have good reason to snap up this out-of-print novel!
Used price: $12.00
Used price: $9.95
Used price: $14.44
Collectible price: $15.00
Used price: $17.99
Buy one from zShops for: $27.90
If you're an artist or a serious Hopper fan, you'll enjoy this book.