List price: $12.95 (that's 20% off!)
outstanding book has taught me a great deal. Outside
of Economic History (Landes, Mokyr, Bairoch, Jones) there
is a depressing lack of works on long-term, integrative
history-perched at a level that the average educated reader
can understand. Pre-Industrial Societies fills that gap
admirably. It is highly informative and extremely well
written.
A brief overview: Pre-Industrial Societies explains how human
society in most of the world (primarily Eurasia) was organized
during the last 4800 of 5000 years-a pretty long time.
That is to say, most of what we refer to as 'History'.
What is unique about Crone's book is that it gives the reader
a *complete* picture of 'The World We Have Lost'.
I would not want to spoil things for the potential reader,
but among many other things she points out how
the Franciscans (or Sufis for that matter) made
excellent use of social 'dropouts', whereas modern
hippies provide society with 'mere nuisance value'!
Pre-Industrial Societies was part of a series of
historical books(hence the un-sexy title);
the other books were not nearly as good.
Aside from Bill McNeill and David Landes,
I know of no other living historian as talented as Crone;
all three share excellent historical skills and
Macaulay-like writting ability. Put these things together
and a great book is practically guaranteed...
The illustrations are as usual delightful and the prose is beautifully expressive of the magic that always seems to exist between the very old and the very young (the Old Dancer and Tanya), between those who share a love of something greater than themselves (dance), and the magic of dress-up (whether in the theater or the play room).
Our own ballerina asked for this story to be read three times the day we brought it home, and has asked for it again every day since. And I can't wait to read it to her again and again.
The heroine's mother is widowed, borrows against her Helena's upcoming marriage only to be told the groom has died in a battle in Spain. Fortunately Clive appears once more and offers his hand in marriage.
I like the detail and characters, the plot seems to involve a number of misunderstandings. Peter's character is slowly exposed and he turns out quite differently than he first appears.
From the dust cover...
SHE HAD ALMOST LOVED HIM BUT NOW SHE DESPISED HIM
Miss Helena Hammond had suffered a tragedy that had left not only herself but her family at Point Non Plus deeply in debt and with no apparent escape. Therefore, Lieutenant Peter Clivedon's appearance was nothing short of a miracle. Aware of the untimely circumstances, but also aware of Helena's breathtaking beauty, Peter offers to marry her, and although greatly surprised, she gratefully accepts. Once married, they move to Whisperwood, and over time, Helena grows very fond of Peter. But their idyllic interlude is shattered when Helena learns that Peter has concealed a terrible truth from her. A truth so painful that Helena is compelled to leave Whisperwood and demand a divorce. Peter knows that what he had done was to protect the woman he so dearly loved. He could only hope she would come to realize this before it was too late.
DAISY MILLER: A STUDY, 1878, is among the principal novellas of history and literature. Very simply, the story involves a young girl Daisy Miller, wandering through Europe, and from America. She is sensitive and capricious. Her ways attract attention, such that perhaps she appears a lustrous woman of carnal desires, or disrespectful to cultures not her own, or stupid. At any event, she catches the eye of another tourist, Mr. Winterbourne, a "nice guy" who not unlike the nice guys of our own world lucks out. He does not get Daisy, but watches as she kisses another and loses herself to unappreciatve men. She does this from anger, resentment, and want of attention. She becomes a symbol of many things, and in the end she dies. The book has been debated for decades.
The dialogue is so well crafted as to be sacred. No further editing of this story is possible, for James took very great pains to edit his work multiple times over. And here, we see a flow of talking and happenings that seem to real to even be on the page. As for instance the communication of Mr. Winterbourne and Daisy's little brother (I believe). The little boys talks, and behaves, as a little boy would. And, Mr. Winterbourne likewise behaves as a young man would to a young boy. Greatest of all are the marvellous dialogues between Daisy and Mr. Winterbourne. They flirt at times, and one feels Winterbourne's longing for her. They feel his sadness, a real sadness, as when she is not feeling for him nearly as deeply. I likened myself to to the man.
I am glad to know that Mr. James was credited as having been "the Master."
What I found was what I have come to expect from James, even in his early works. This book does a great deal in terms of pulling together many levels of interpretaion: Old World versus New World, common versus exclusive, and also the chaser and the chased.
This last viewpoint in particular is what stuck with me. We have a young girl, and a young man. They meet once for a few days, and the young man becomes utterly fixated on her, if for any other reason that she is playing, in his view, hard to get. When she turns her attention elsewhere, the ante is doubled and tripled when, for a variety of reasons most likely centered around our young hero Winterbourne, the American society in Rome starts to give our heroin the "cold shoulder". Given that James writes most often to examine the person most in focus in the novel, I tend to atribute most of the troubles of this young girl to both herself and Winterbourne, not just the society of the time. This is far from a safe academic interpretation, however.
The notes included in the book are helpful for getting into the mindset of the typical reader of James' day, but are not distracting. Overall, this would probably be suitible for an ambitios middle school student, and just right for most high school students.
Andrew Larson, Indiana Communications Major