Used price: $36.16
Collectible price: $34.94
Used price: $6.20
Collectible price: $8.00
Used price: $6.08
Collectible price: $26.47
First, although the comparisons to Nick Hornby's High Fidelity are inevitable, this book doesn't quite measure up. Hornby's book was full of meaningful musical references most of us could get - when Rob was ripping U2, or putting some Motown R&B artists on his turntable, the reader could relate. Here, in Never Mind Nirvana, readers might get a little overwhelmed with the attention to detail given Seattle's 1990's grunge scene, since most of us don't know Temple of the Dog from Mother Love Bone.
Plus, in Hornby's book, the other characters have a lot more depth to them, especially the female ones. Here, women are seen more as targets for pick-up efforts by protagonist Pete Tyler and his prosecuting sidekick Scott Foss. Accordingly this book really strikes me as a guy book, that I would recommend to male friends but not females. Some reviewers have complained that the date rape trial which sets the plot in motion is given short thrift, and I must say the courtroom scenes were some of my favorite in the novel, but I don't think Lindquist set out to write a courtroom thriller about that subject. He set out to write a book about a 37 year old former rocker who is forced, by this case, to reassess his lifestyle and attitudes toward women.
As for the ending, which some have called unsatisfying, I thought the book ended perfectly. Hollywood might tie things up a little more neatly if they ever adapted this to the screen, but I found the end of the novel dead on and consistent with the preceding chapters.
A couple of final trivial complaints. Lindquist uses smoking and drinking a little too much, like a writer's crutch, having Pete and his companions constantly reaching for a Camel or a scotch every two pages to give them something to do. I was getting headaches just imagining the smell of stale smoke and scotch whiskey. Also, while every character he meets seems to remember Pete and his band Morph, at one point several people in a club confuse a band member from Alice in Chains for a guy from Pearl Jam. In Seattle, we are to believe fans recognize a bassist from Morph and yet mistake a member of Pearl Jam? Finally, I found the present tense narrative style a little unsettling at the start, but once the novel got going I quickly settled into the author's pace and forgot about it.
In summary, I enjoyed Mark's book and read it very quickly (perfect airplane reading I might add). Had Lindquist concentrated a little more on the other characters, and a little less on obscure Seattle nightclubs and artists foreign to most of us, he'd be basking in more 5 star reviews.
That description sounds a lot more serious than the book actually is. The characters in this book are really amusing. Pete's commitmentphobia and his fear/dread of aging, being alone, selling out will ring true to anyone in their thirties. This book reminded me a lot of Nic!k Hornby's High Fidelity (although it doesn't rise to the cult classic-ness of that book) and at times I think it was intentional (i.e., certain breakups make his top ten regrets of all time)
For a quick read, there is alot to chew on in this novel--regret, responsibility, aging, loneliness, commitment. All these serious topics, however, arise in a funny, not so serious novel that is a pleasure to read. It's the perfect book to take to the beach and then lend to all of your friends.
Used price: $13.50
Used price: $25.47
List price: $31.50 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $7.34
Buy one from zShops for: $18.31