Buy one from zShops for: $28.99
Used price: $14.00
Collectible price: $14.82
Used price: $10.70
Buy one from zShops for: $34.00
Lieb's approach to Milton is in three parts, in which he describes Milton in terms of the archetype of the Orpheic poet torn to pieces by wild women, the Old Testament view of the virgin-matron, and then integrates these images with his interpretation of Milton as artist and politician who re-visions himself in the context of such mythic images and in light of Milton's own discourse with contemporaries. Lieb begins each section by setting up the recurrent theme of violent dismemberment and loss in Greco-Roman and Biblical myths which he sees as the basis of Milton's works, discussing the stories of Orpheus, of the Levites concubine ravished by the Benjaminites and of blind Samson.
He also discusses the violence inherent in the political-religious arena of Milton's day that allowed the beheading of a king, the mutilation and disembowelment of the regicides, and atrocities like massacre of the Waldensians at Piedmont in 1655. Pointing to Milton's Sonnet 18, written in response to the incident in Piedmont, Lieb argues that Milton's abhorrence of extreme violence involving mutilation, dismemberment, or any rending of the physical body stems not just from his equation of the individual body with the rending of the Body of Christ, i.e.: the Church. Lieb, while recognizing the Milton's equation of the Orpheic poet torn apart by Bacchantes with the crucified Christ as integral to Milton's own religious vision, also sees a deeper "Secret History" in Milton's work in which Milton is relating his own identification with and fear of physical dismemberment or sparagmos. To emphasize his point Lieb draws directly on Miltonic texts and sets up parallels between these and specific incidents in Milton's personal life and career.
In part two of his book, Lieb introduces the story of the rape and death of the Levite's concubine and discusses Milton's treatment of females images, particularly in Paradise Lost. Lieb's argument here is that Milton is revisiting the issue of female rape from a sociopolitical perspective. Lieb feels that Milton's own gender crisis stems from his university days and a nickname he acquired, "the Lady of Christ's College," which was based in the fairness of his coloration and an effeminacy of carriage. Lieb takes this incident a step further insisting that Milton's own fragile sexual self-identity was shaped here and, further, that it is then reflected in his treatment of female figures in his text. Milton, Lieb says, is seeking to subsume his own internal female/bisexuality in the gender role reversals of "dominant female" figures like the Domina defending her chastity in A Mask, and Eve coercing Adam in Paradise Lost.
Lieb also points to Milton's divorce tracts, claiming Milton's intention here is a more liberal interpretation of the issue of fornication and adultery, which, according to Lieb, stems from Milton's own identification with the Levite's concubine of Judges 19 and reinterprets female "whoorishness" as not simply a sexual behavior but as woman in argument with male authority. Lieb claims Milton's own sexual identity is at issue here and uses Rabbinical critiques to reinforce his view of Milton's text as reflecting Milton's struggle to come to grips with his own bisexual leanings. Milton, says Lieb, must reevaluate and reinstate the female through his writing to come to grips with his own internal virgin-matron complex.
Milton's struggle with self-identity is also the focus of part three of Lieb's book in which Lieb now places a new historicist twist into what has, so far, been a psychological (almost Freudian) interpretation of Milton the poet. Here Lieb makes his most far-reaching claim, that it is Milton's own self-fashioning that is revealed in Samson Agonistes. Lieb draws from Milton's polemic tracts, specifically Pro Se Defensio and Defensio Secunda, to define what he calls Milton's "theatre of assault" in which the now blind poet is effectively reshaping and reclaiming his own reputation and reestablishing his self-identity as masculine, virile, and physically whole. Quoting Milton's condemnation of those who would mock him, Lieb points out Milton's feelings of self-rightness and divine favor and sees them in a Pauline paradox of "strength perfected in weakness." By refashioning his own physical bodily repristination in the destruction of his adversaries, Lieb argues, Milton is protecting himself from the internal femininity and the external dismemberment, sparagmos, he has always feared.
Throughout his work, Lieb uses Biblical references to tease out hidden meanings in Milton's texts. He supports his arguments with both textual material from Milton's writings and anecdotal evidence from Milton's life, and yet one can't help but feel that Lieb is occasionally reaching too far in the conclusions he draws, particularly in the third section where he sees intentional direction on the part of the poet as "self-refashioner." Lieb does argue with great erudition, which is apparent both in his conscious use of language and his remarkable ability to draw inferences from Milton's sources in both Classical and Biblical myth. He does tend to build, not on, but rather more often against, the current criticism of other Milton scholars. Over all this is an exceptional piece of scholarly piece of writing, aimed at serious Milton scholars and well worth reading whether or not one accepts Lieb's thesis on the crisis of Milton's self-identity. What Lieb has provided here is a fascinating, and well cross-referenced, theory that is not for the faint-hearted or fair-weather scholar.
Used price: $9.45
Collectible price: $9.53