Used price: $17.95
Collectible price: $69.96
Buy one from zShops for: $4.99
Buy one from zShops for: $34.85
List price: $29.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $14.95
Collectible price: $15.88
Buy one from zShops for: $14.95
List price: $14.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $11.95
Collectible price: $16.99
I would tell anyone interested in a fast-paced, beautiful story, to pick up a copy of this book.
And the ending? My God, hold on...
Used price: $1.60
Collectible price: $9.95
Buy one from zShops for: $9.95
The book itself was good. The plot was interesting, the characters memorable and Levin really has a way with words. Many of his descriptions are unique and very effective. His character development is amazing (even if some of them were only around for a few pages) but I could not, in all good conscience, give this book a higher rating due to the MANY typos.
As a PR person who works with many authors I found these errors highly disturbing. For instance calling a glock a gluck and constantly changing tense in mid-sentence. The continuity problems also bothered me - in the beginning of the book they headed chapters that take place in the past by saying "five years earlier" but forgo this later in the book which made the read VERY confusing. Since Levin jumps back and forth so often it is hard to keep track.
Besides the basics of editing - this book was enjoyable and I would recommend it to others as long as you can overlook the proofing problems. If Levin could get "Lizard" or his next book picked up by a bigger publishing house or if Voyage Books put a little more money into the marketing (and editing) of this book it could have been a big hit. Reviewers like nothing more than a talented, creative new writer. Let's hope Levin makes the most of it and pushes for a second run with more PR.
The idea behind Boston Medical Publishing's "pearls of wisdom" series (not to be confused with the higher quality Hanley & Belfus' "Pearls" Series)is a good one: publish a series of books in the various specialties that consist entirely of questions and answers in the various subtopics within those specialties.
However, the execution is weak for the following reasons:
1. Inaccuracies/mistakes.
I recently looked through the pediatrics text (latest, 2nd edition) at my bookshop (it was one of the few subjects initially available there). During some 20 minutes of browsing, I found 2 definite errors, and one ambiguity. Medicine is one field where I think there should be an *extremely* low tolerance for less than sterling writing. Note: the mistakes I found were not gray areas - they were not in complex management issues where there can be more than one right answer. These were clear cut factual errors that could have been avoided by more careful editing.
2. Poor referencing.
I know the authors state in their preface (which is a standard preface used in all the different subjects in the series!) that their intention wasn't to reference. But I think in this day and age of Evidence based medicine, literature citations are of paramount importance - not only to demonstrate a thorough understanding of the literature on all the topics, but so that readers may reach for the best review/original paper where necessary. In this regard, the "Secrets" series published by Hanley and Belfus are simply outstanding. They reference (often with multiple citations) each and every question/answer!!
3. Coverage
A minor, but not unimportant criticism is the coverage. I found that for the price I paid, the coverage of topics could have been better. If the authors could increase the questions by 2/3, I feel they will have a MUCH better book. Questions should stress more pathology, diagnostics (esp. diff diagnosis and clinical approach), and management.
4. For its shortcomings, the price (about USD 88.00) is astonishing. These books are merely a compilation of questions and answers for exam review, not comprehensive full colour textbooks! I do not understand why it should cost that much, when cost of production should be low - no pictures, no diagrams, no references even. Just one line questions and several line answers. The price is, i feel, unfair.
Conclusion:
Buy it only if:
1. You are prepared to double check every answer/statement against authoritative textbooks and the literature.
2. You can afford to throw your money on a good, but less than ideal product.
3. You want to get your hands on every review book available for revision purposes.
His Bialik translations, though he didn't care for Bialik, withstand examination by other Bialik lovers: "Once again, dreaming a giant dream/men hasten to their little sins." A crisp, elegant rendering. Likewise his versions of Rachel: "A true pact is ours, a tie time cannot dissever/Only what I have lost is what I possess forever." He can make these modern Hebrew poets sound like eighteenth century London wits. But with the colloquial and contemporary Amichai he stumbles: "All the generations that preceded me contributed me/in small amounts..." Here "contributed me" echoes the Hebrew locution in a way not possible in English and the chattiness of the original stiffens to alien brocade. Friend succeeds where a not quite twentieth century "poetic" English is appropriate, fails where conversational tone is required.
No small part of this book's appeal and usefulness as a general introduction are Levin's laconic, evocative biographical notes: Gabriel Preil, born in Estonia, settled to write Hebrew poetry in the United States and "died while on a visit to Jerusalem, awaiting the publication of his Collected Poems". Lonely souls translated by a lonely voice, far in time and spirit from contemporary English and its streetsmart verse.