Related Subjects: Author Index
Book reviews for "Klimas,_Antanas" sorted by average review score:

Beginner's Lithuanian
Published in Paperback by Hippocrene Books (1998)
Authors: Leonardas Dambriunas, William R. Schmalstieg, and Antanas Klimas
Amazon base price: $13.97
List price: $19.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $10.00
Buy one from zShops for: $13.82
Average review score:

Native speaker's perspective
As a native speaker of Lithuanian, I am not terribly impressed with this textbook. It looks like a classical old-fashioned language teaching methodology, something like "high school Latin" sort of thing. I have a similar experience of learning English at school from a similar type of textbook, and this experience did not seem like a whole load of fun, to say the least... What you find in the textbbook is the oversimplified, "sterilized" version of Lithuanian, which although grammatically correct and fine for most formal occasions, will be very different from what you will actually hear if you walk in the streets of Siauliai. I think the learners would do better with the teaching course which gives some natural language, natural examples, taken from the real-life situations. In this textbook, however, the sterilized version of Lithuanian will take you no further than highly formal version of Language of e.g. government meetings or radio news... As I've already mentioned, I had exactly the same experience while learning English, so you can trust my words:)

It'll Work in a Pinch
As somone who has worked as a professional linguist, I find the book adequate, but very poorly organized and difficult to use. On the other hand, it's about the best that's out there. Unfortunately.

As a linguist, my first priority is to grasp the basic structure of a language so that if I run across a word, phrase, or article, the most I'll need in order to understand it is a good dictionary. This book only gives up that kind of knowledge very grudgingly.

Instead of explaining basic grammar rules, the text relies heavily on examples. While verb conjugation and noun declension are mentioned in the first three chapters, along with a small handfull of examples, the basic rules governing these things are not explained. No matter how commonly exceptions to the rules occur in any given language, there will still be basic rules of grammar. This is where instruction should begin, with the complexity of phases being built up as new rules are introduced. Exceptions can always be dealt with in later chapters. Instead this text mentions grammar forms without explanation, then tries to teach declined nouns and conjugated verbs as seperate vocabulary.

I think the book's authors may have been trying for a balance between in-depth grammar and giving the student handy phrases to be used from day one. Unfortunately they came up with a very poor compromise that gives little of either in any useful way.

In conjunction with classroom instruction by a competent teacher, I think the book is adequate. However, as an aid to learning Lithuanian on one's own, it is unnecessarily difficult to use, cumbersome, and incomplete.

As to the criticism of other reviewers that it is too outdated and stiff, personally I prefer an instructional text that is dense and to the point. As someone who learns languages quickly and aggressively, that fits my style. However, as a teacher I agree that a text that is more fun would make the process easier for most students, especially those with little or no experience in learning languages. Unfortunately this book really fits neither my style nor the more enjoyable style of modern laguage texts.

In a very small field of options, this book is probably the best. With a good bit of effort on the student's part, it is usable. However, it is far from being what I would call "good".

Not for the faint of heart!
Lithuanian is a very complex, difficult language to learn. This book gives some very good guidance; however, if you are trying to learn the language on your own, I think you might run into problems. If you know someone who speaks fluent Lithuanian who can help you and explain things further, this book is great!


Related Subjects: Author Index

Reviews are from readers at Amazon.com. To add a review, follow the Amazon buy link above.