Used price: $0.70
Collectible price: $4.99
Buy one from zShops for: $6.99
Used price: $3.23
Collectible price: $6.00
Now, just let me say, I LOVE THIS SERIES! I especially love the character of Taliesin. He is my favorite from all of Morrison's books and possibly from any others I have ever read. His voice is exceptionally distinctive in the telling and very consistent. He is a very unassuming character, terrified out of his wits most of the time and sure that everyone knows it, yet is completely honest about this fact. I love the style of these books too. The prose is perhaps a bit cumbersome when you first begin reading but it is defiantly an epic tale, every event fraught with dan from now 'till nevermass, and all the characters with the seeds of greatness in them, Arthur most of all. I love this particular universe because it is so imaginative, Celtic legend mixed with sciencficiton in a successful blending.
Now, the Kirkus reviewer has a point when he says that Patricia Kennealy-Morrison has a "general air of self-importance". He hits the nail right on the head. She is continually prating on the virtues of the Kelts. How they are so much more evolved than "other societies I could name" in that they have magical arts, no rape, varying marriage laws, and women are considered equals. It is an attitude hard to avoid throughout her books, but this is the only detraction I will make and, you will admit, not a very serious one.
If you have read the Copper Crown and its counterparts you will be intrigued when you discover that the writing style is completely different from the first triology. This is writen in first rather than third person. It is rare that an author has such talent as to switch styles. The style change means that you will never tire of the Keltiad. Instead of boresdom you will find love for the lore as past history links all the books together.
Used price: $0.57
Collectible price: $2.12
Buy one from zShops for: $18.50
Used price: $8.50
Collectible price: $8.99
This story is amazing. It's not just the plot, although that gets my highest praise for being so intricate and well-written. But, the world that has been created around the plot is so stunning and beautiful that I can't describe it. You just have to go there for yourself.
Enough background-- what I really want to say is how much fun this is to read, how smart it is, and how well written it is as well. The characters come to life for the reader and stay with them long after you finish reading the book. Dare I say "a classic"? (NOTE: This is all coming from someone who is not a sci-fi/ fantasy nut but someone who reads all genres of literature.)
Used price: $0.88
Collectible price: $3.18
The novel's main flaw is that almost all its characters are made of cardboard; the Good Kelts vs. Nasty Imperials. Most of the Kelts (and other characters) are so insufferably perfect in almost every way that one can hardly tell they're human at all. This in the end means that its hard to at all identify with them or get swept up by their various trials and triumphs, and that is a fatal flaw in any story. There are some scenes that hint that there is a possibility of much, much more to these characters, but they are far too few. I have not read the sequel yet, and can only hope that the characters' depictions improve as the story goes on. However, this novel itself is average at best.
Used price: $8.99
Buy one from zShops for: $19.90
This is a series that simply didn't work for me. I've been told that Kennealy considers this to be a sci-fi series more than a fantasy, and yet, there isn't any actual science in them. Ships and the rare computers are controlled by crystals. Horses still seem to provide 99.9% of transportation. Bedding is made of fur. There are no paternity tests, apparently (an important plot point). This is not a scientific world. It is a fantasy, pure and simple.
Also, there are no surprises. Kennealy invokes "dan" (karma, fate, doom, whatever) at every corner, meaning that each and every major plot point is revealed well before it becomes an issue. I found myself rolling my eyes, wondering what the Kelts would think of us Terrans, who aren't given the opportunity to know EXACTLY what we'll be having for breakfast in forty years, much less EXACTLY how long we'll live, who we'll marry, what the names of our grandchildren will be, what our great and mystical destiny will be...
My friend was excited to tell me that there was no Lancelet figure in this series. Well, excepting Keils, there wasn't...but Lancelet is an important part of the Arthur legend. A very, very important part. Because, you see, it is mostly as a result of the whole Gwen/Lance thing that Arthur nanced off to get himself killed, and Camelot fell.
Last major gripe: there is no character development anywhere here. Oh, sure, characters grow up, and grow older, but they don't change must. (Okay, okay, Gweniver changes a bit, over the course of her hundred or so year lifespan.) No, Taliesin is the same person at 100 that he was at five. Donah and Loherin and Tarian and all these other character appear and move offstage without the reader ever having any insight into their being.
All of that said, there were some wonderful parts in this trilogy: the Yamazai were extremely cool, as was the whole "Hedge of Mist" idea, the idea of Taliesin's mother being from earth...probably the scene that moved me most was Arthur and company's demise, which I will not spoil for those of you intent upon reading this book.
Taliesin is a great character, and a great narrator, tempered by humor and anger and love and loyalty, and one is left with the impression that there could be no better bard to tell this story. If only the whole first HALF of this book didn't feel like such a death march to the end...
you'll love it. don't try to start one without having both of the others with you.
Used price: $2.00
Collectible price: $14.85
Used price: $3.00
Collectible price: $14.84
List price: $17.00 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $8.50
Collectible price: $12.71
Buy one from zShops for: $10.85
Used price: $3.49
Collectible price: $9.48
Buy one from zShops for: $2.70
The least we could hope for is an interesting way to be offended, but nope. Don't waste your money. No worry you'd waste your time, because it's unreadable.
Anyway, the story was okay, but not as riveting as some of her other books, certainly nothing in comparison to the Throne of Scone. It took too long to get away from Earth, and then didn't spend enough time in Keltia. I would have liked a lot more about Brendan's mother, Nia and for most of the supporting cast to have given a little more attention. If her books continue to be pagan propaganda, I'll stick with the first books and forget whatever else is planned. Which is too bad, because I have really enjoyed the Keltic saga until the past two books.