List price: $14.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $9.95
Buy one from zShops for: $9.82
I do have to knock off one star for the lack of color, but it's still a solid 4 star book for the sheer amount of material presented at such a low cost.
The collected stories are reprints of "Tales of Suspense", the book that featured Cap before he got his own title, from issue #59 (his first appearance in the series) to issue #99. At issue #100 the book was re-titled "Captain America", and issues 100, 101, and 102 are included as well.
Essential Captain America Vol. 2 picks up at issue #103 and runs up to issue #126. But before you criticize 40+ issues in volume 1 vs. 20+ issues in volume 2 , realize that "Tales of Suspense" was a book split between Cap and Iron Man. There may be half the issues in volume 2, but they're twice as long. It all balances out, really.
Just be careful what you expect vs. which volume you order since the same reviews post for both volumes.
The only problem (aside from the black and white that people love to moan about) is some of the writing doesn't hold up so well by today's standards. (Insert "Golly!" here. Or mention somebody in "deadly danger".) Although as long as you take into account the time period this was written in, it's just fine.
Including Avengers issue #4 would have been nice too, since it's Cap's first (true) appearance since WWII, but I guess there's always volumes of Essential Avengers... All things considered, if you want a full run of Cap's coninuity, this is the most financially responsible decision you can make.
Used price: $0.75
Collectible price: $2.12
Surprise twist ending...bittersweet, exciting, fast paced. Worth reading! I no longer have my copy of it and would love to read it again.
Used price: $11.99
Buy one from zShops for: $10.58
Used price: $4.95
Used price: $9.00
Used price: $14.00
Collectible price: $26.47
Buy one from zShops for: $64.77
Buy one from zShops for: $22.47
Used price: $3.44
Buy one from zShops for: $3.24
Used price: $10.59