Used price: $3.95
Collectible price: $5.29
Buy one from zShops for: $15.00
List price: $24.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $11.74
Buy one from zShops for: $9.90
Worst is Posner's coverage of individuals, especially Gordy himself. Since Posner admits that he interviewed nobody, then his descriptions of a person's private thoughts and beliefs, which he attempts frequently, can only be copied straight from other biographies with little surrounding context. Posner also easily joins the parade of disparagement against Diana Ross, who may just deserve people's wrath, but you should be suspicious when a person is criticized but is not there to give their side of the story. Posner also gets in over his head when trying to analyze the complex personalities of Marvin Gaye and Stevie Wonder. Finally his slow-moving writing style doesn't give you the incentive to turn the pages, and the end of the story is appallingly weak with a halfhearted attempt to wrap up Motown's place in history.
If you are interested in the classic music of Motown and its talented stars, go elsewhere, please. This book does a better job of analyzing the business of Motown but is too fragmented and second-hand for true believability. If you're interested in that subject, also go elsewhere.
Since this isn't a book of encyclopedic length, it has to focus on certain key points and that means a lot gets left out. And though many artists contributed to Motown's fabulous accomplishments, the book centers on Berry Gordy, Jr., his founding of the company, how he gathered all that amazing talent, and how Motow provided an environment where that talent could develop and flourish.
The book also focuses on the biggest acts and on those employees who were closest to Gordy. Necessarily, a lot of talented and wonderful people get left out of this telling of the story. THe book is just over 300 pages and it would take thousands of pages to tell something approaching a complete history of Motown. However, this book is delightful to read and gets those of us without inside knowledge closer to these personalities than many of us have every been.
There are so many different and passionate views about who deserves credit for what in all the successes of Motown and who deserves blame for all the various failures that no book can satisfy everyone. However, Mr. Posner has done a great deal to talk to as many folks as would talk with him, did a lot of reading, and dug into court records to find out what really went on. He found out a lot about the truth of the charges and counter charges in key court cases and business practices that existed in Motown over the decades of its existence. The book takes an even handed view and isn't afraid to tell us about Mr. Gordy's rather sharp business practices, the self-delusion and self-destruction of many artists, as well as the glorious way they pulled together in the early years to make themselves into huge stars. The book isn't a puff piece, but it also doesn't drag the people discussed in the book through the mud.
If you haven't already made up your mind, I think you will enjoy this book very much. At least, I can say that I did. Thanks, Mr. Posner!
Used price: $16.80
Collectible price: $17.70
Used price: $15.19
Buy one from zShops for: $14.95
Used price: $19.98
Collectible price: $19.01
Buy one from zShops for: $19.78
Used price: $20.00
Collectible price: $51.88
Used price: $24.07
Buy one from zShops for: $29.00
Used price: $30.00
This book also, for me, placed a human side to Berry Gordy and not the myth and mega businessman.
This book also told, what I believe is the real story about the stars and artist who help build "Hitsville USA".
I recommend this book to all Motown, Gordy fans. It's fascinating and informative as well as a 60's history lesson.
Bravo to Raynoma Gordy Singleton for her honesty and humor.