List price: $16.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $6.54
Collectible price: $12.16
Buy one from zShops for: $6.95
List price: $16.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $9.95
Buy one from zShops for: $11.17
From the very first page, I was swept into the story. My own beloved dog had died just a week before I read this novel, and so the character of Dog especially appealed to me. It is not easy to fully develop an animal character in a realistic novel, but Chan achieves this admirably. I had tears in my eyes as I read it. Dog was so "real" that I could almost pat him!
And the historical research! As a historical novelist myself, I am very picky when I read other historicals, but this one is spot-on. Bravo!
I also loved the touch of fantasy.
The Carved Box is a universal tale that transcends age limits.
Used price: $2.13
Collectible price: $5.25
Buy one from zShops for: $12.15
Used price: $4.68
Buy one from zShops for: $10.97
All the stories in this collection are told in the fist person, which gives them an immediacy and authenticity. Gillian Chan is a adult, but she captures the cynicism toward adults and the adult world that many teens feel. In the title story, Donna, the daughter of a factory worker, is painfully aware of the differences between her life-chances and those the her supposed best friend Anna, the 'Golden Girl,' whose father is the richest man in town. When Anna breezily refers to a local factory owner by his first name, Donna tells the reader that all she knew about the man is that she would "do just about anything not to end up working for him when I was out of school." Anna's obliviousness to class differences makes Donna's clear-sighted observations of them all the more poignant.
The adults in this book are not particularly competent or even likable. In "Elly, Nel and Eleanor," the father, instead of protecting his daughter from her neurotic mother, waltzes out on them both. In "Small-Town Napoleon," the protagonist's mother sympathizes with her son's desire to act in the school play, but is unable to effectively stand up for his right to do so, or to protect him from his father's foul temper. While a few of the teachers are portrayed as sympathetic (particularly to the 'good' students) others range from incompetent to malicious. In 'The Buddy System," Dennis tells us that one teacher, having contended for years with the Buddy's four older brothers, takes "a sick satisfaction in seeing Buddy suffer."
A strong feature of this book is the way characters pop up in more than one story. Bob, the villain of the first story, is also the sympathetically portrayed protagonist of the last one. This gives the book a depth that it would otherwise lack, and serves to remind young readers that there is such a thing as 'unreliable narration' (in life as well as art).
I would recommend this book to anyone who is, was, or is about to become, a teenager.