Related Subjects: Author Index Reviews Page 1 2
Book reviews for "Brooke-Rose,_Christine" sorted by average review score:

Interpretation and Overinterpretation
Published in Paperback by Cambridge Univ Pr (Pap Txt) (March, 1992)
Authors: Umberto Eco, Stefan Collini, Jonathan Culler, Richard Rorty, and Christine Brooke-Rose
Amazon base price: $49.95
Used price: $52.57
Average review score:

Dense material in a very compact, readable form
When reading a text, how much does what the author intended count for, if anything? Is there any way to tell what a text "really" means, or can it be read however you like for whatever purpose you like? Simple as they seem, these are the fundamental questions this book is concerned with, and it is Eco's task to explain why he thinks there should be limits to interpretation - against the prevailing opinions of many modern critics and thinkers.

The book is laid out in eight sections. The first is the Introduction, which is substantial. If you're in the habit of skipping the introduction I would advise against it here, unless you consider yourself thoroughly familiar with the subject - it's helpful.

The next three sections consist of a series of lectures Eco gave on this subject, where he establishes his main points. It's quite accessible to the layman, and in the few places where the terms get a bit obscure you can usually figure out what he's talking about from the context. He uses several historical examples which keep things interesting, and his arguments are interesting whether you find them convincing or not.

Essays by Rorty, Culler and Brooke-Rose in response to these lectures make up the next part. Rorty, a self-described "pragmatist", makes the argument that we shouldn't concern ourselves with what makes a "valid" interpretation, and instead just use texts as they come before us for whatever purpose suits us best. Culler, coming from the side of the deconstructionists, argues that what Eco calls "overinterpretation" has a value of its own and reacts strongly to the implication that there should be any limits whatsoever imposed upon the critic. Brooke-Rose's piece on "palimpsest history" is not uninteresting but somewhat tangential, and you really have to stretch things to relate it to the argument going on between Eco, Rorty and Culler.

The wrap-up section is a response from Eco, mostly addressing Rorty's points though dealing somewhat with Culler's objections. There is no clear "winner", and you may not be swayed to Eco's point of view if you found one of the others more compelling, but there is ample food for thought.

Even for the non-academic, a great insightfull book
I don't have much background in literary theory, but I still found Eco's writing very accessible and very enjoyable. I think the topic would interest anyone that has ever tried to appreciate literature: up to what point can we take events in a book/play/poem to be significant to the idea the writer is trying to get across?

This book constructs its arguments from the ground up, although at times the approach to interpretation taken by Eco is radically different from how one would be accustumed to reading a book.

I believe that eventually one gets used to the different approaches suggested -- or better, exemplified -- by Eco, and the initial difficulties in understanding his point of view are overcome to open a great new horizon of ideas and literary enjoyment.


Amalgamemnon
Published in Paperback by Dalkey Archive Pr (July, 1994)
Author: Christine Brooke-Rose
Amazon base price: $11.95
Used price: $6.55
Buy one from zShops for: $8.29
Average review score:

A virtuoso monologue
To give a plot synopsis of this novel would be almost pointless because the book is all about voice. The narrator spills out words and puns and jams them together (as in the title) to make new words, thus forcing the reader to think in new ways about how the words relate. It is also a novel of ideas, and in many ways, a novel about power. The narrator posits herself as Cassandra to the various Agamemnon's (thus amalgamemnon) that ignore her. Technnology, capitalism, and Wester, male-dominated society are all forces that she struggles with. Interestingly, Brooke-Rose also foresees the power of terrorism and the threat of fundamentalism that responds to these same sources of powers. To be sure, though, this is mostly a novel about language, and if you don't enjoy playful, postmodern punning, then skip this one.


Textermination
Published in Paperback by New Directions Publishing (October, 1992)
Author: Christine Brooke-Rose
Amazon base price: $10.95
Used price: $2.67
Buy one from zShops for: $2.95
Average review score:

a cultural smorgasbord
Textermination is an excellent book, but be warned - it is not an 'easy' read. Set at a convention of characters from literature, it is crowded with overt and subtle references to, and quotes and characters from, a huge number of sources. There will be books and authors you have never heard of mentioned in this book, and it can make you feel very small. There are also passages in French, German, Spanish and other languages. Those challenges aside, this book is worth reading for the way it engages narrative conventions, separating and subverting the roles of characters, authors, the "Reader", and more. Brooke-Rose's use of language is inspiring.


Between
Published in Unknown Binding by Joseph ()
Author: Christine Brooke-Rose
Amazon base price: $
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Go when you see the green man walking
Published in Unknown Binding by Joseph ()
Author: Christine Brooke-Rose
Amazon base price: $
Average review score:
No reviews found.

A grammar of metaphor
Published in Unknown Binding by Secker & Warburg ()
Author: Christine Brooke-Rose
Amazon base price: $64.50
Average review score:
No reviews found.

In Transit: An Heroi-Cyclic Novel
Published in Paperback by Dalkey Archive Pr (July, 2002)
Authors: Brigid Brophy and Christine Brooke-Rose
Amazon base price: $11.60
List price: $14.50 (that's 20% off!)
Used price: $7.50
Buy one from zShops for: $6.95
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Interpretación y sobreinterpretación
Published in Paperback by Cambridge Univ Pr (Trd) (November, 1995)
Authors: Umberto Eco, Stefan Collini, Jonathan Culler, Richard Rorty, and Christine Brooke-Rose
Amazon base price: $12.00
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Christine Brooke-Rose and Contemporary Fiction
Published in Hardcover by Clarendon Pr (March, 1994)
Author: Sarah Birch
Amazon base price: $75.00
Used price: $29.95

The Christine Brooke-Rose Omnibus: Four Novels: Out, Such, Between, Thru
Published in Paperback by Carcanet Press Ltd (August, 1986)
Author: Christine Brooke-Rose
Amazon base price: $19.95
Used price: $11.00

Related Subjects: Author Index Reviews Page 1 2

Reviews are from readers at Amazon.com. To add a review, follow the Amazon buy link above.