Book reviews for "Bloch,_Marc_Léopold_Benjamin" sorted by average review score:
French Rural History: An Essay on Its Basic Characteristics
Published in Paperback by University of California Press (January, 1970)
Amazon base price: $19.95
Used price: $2.50
Collectible price: $7.00
Buy one from zShops for: $14.99
Used price: $2.50
Collectible price: $7.00
Buy one from zShops for: $14.99
Average review score:
Explains the often undocumented evolution of rural societies
I read the Spanish translation of this book for a graduate course and it became a crucial reference for other scholarly work I am doing now. While urban history is often well documented, rural history is a huge question mark. As a result, most of the history we know is that of urban societies. Bloch's work is outstanding, since he decides to reconstruct history from the evidence still left in the present. He "moves backward in the line of history" and uses all types of evidence available to "record change". Change, he says, is the only evidence left of rural history. For example, he researches how people organized agricultural parcels, how they named their towns, why and how they mark their territories, how different agricultural activites coexisted, what where their agricultural techniques, and their rationale... And, while doing that, he reconstructs the imperatives of these medieval times, the crucial forces acting upon people in their often isolated communities. Most important, he addresses why and how these practices changed. Through these changes, he is able to document history. Events that although crucial, were not recorded in history books, in archives, in chronicles, etc. Still, they had paramount importance in the evolution of French society. This book is universal, since it allows us to understand not only French history, but overall rural history as well. For example, one can understand how medieval agricultural practices had an impact in the long and narrow shape of the plots of land parceled in the initial settlements of the United States. In addition, it shows us that change is very slow, and that many elements of medieval society are still with us today.
Strange Defeat: A Statement of Evidence Written in 1940
Published in Paperback by W.W. Norton & Company (February, 1968)
Amazon base price: $9.95
Used price: $0.66
Buy one from zShops for: $4.00
Used price: $0.66
Buy one from zShops for: $4.00
Average review score:
Superb evaluation of the French Defeat
I keep returning to this book as among the best I've ever read. It is both good reading as military history and failure analysis: no one has been able to write so deftly and originally about why France fell so swiftly in 1940. Unlike other military history books, this one is not heavy on maps nor units nor armament, merely a very incisive and friendly discussion of why France fells so quickly.
Serving in both WW1 and WW2, he points a litany of reasons why the French army, which was better equipted than the Germans, collapsed so suddenly. Despite what I learned in highschool about the French defeat of WW2 (France was overconfident in the Maginot Line), Marc Bloch tells a different reason. The French army, aside from its reliance on the Maginot Line, failed to anticipate how modern weapons shortened space. The French army never understood how the speed of modern weapons had shortened space. Marc Bloch, serving at the front in 1940, recalled that the German offensive actually seem to overtake each French retreat: whenever Marc Bloch's unit retreated in 1940, they constantly found the Germans in their rear. The consequence was the French army was in a perpetual retreat and lacked the time to mount a proper counter offensive.
Marc Bloch also points to the cultural factors in the French defeat, namely the French education system which ignored history and visual arts in its cirriculum. He proposes a greater emphasis on both. I agree with the latter: in the US, we are saturated with images but we are visually illiterate. As for history, there is now too much emphasis on history without a comparable attempt to work things out in the present. This is a terrific book that reads like a no-holds barred fight.
Serving in both WW1 and WW2, he points a litany of reasons why the French army, which was better equipted than the Germans, collapsed so suddenly. Despite what I learned in highschool about the French defeat of WW2 (France was overconfident in the Maginot Line), Marc Bloch tells a different reason. The French army, aside from its reliance on the Maginot Line, failed to anticipate how modern weapons shortened space. The French army never understood how the speed of modern weapons had shortened space. Marc Bloch, serving at the front in 1940, recalled that the German offensive actually seem to overtake each French retreat: whenever Marc Bloch's unit retreated in 1940, they constantly found the Germans in their rear. The consequence was the French army was in a perpetual retreat and lacked the time to mount a proper counter offensive.
Marc Bloch also points to the cultural factors in the French defeat, namely the French education system which ignored history and visual arts in its cirriculum. He proposes a greater emphasis on both. I agree with the latter: in the US, we are saturated with images but we are visually illiterate. As for history, there is now too much emphasis on history without a comparable attempt to work things out in the present. This is a terrific book that reads like a no-holds barred fight.
Apologie pour l'histoire, ou, Métier d'historien
Published in Unknown Binding by A. Colin ()
Amazon base price: $
Used price: $82.36
Used price: $82.36
Average review score:
No reviews found.
Die Erben von Bloch und Febvre : Annales-Geschichtsschreibung und nouvelle histoire in Frankreich 1945-1980
Published in Unknown Binding by Klett-Cotta ()
Amazon base price: $
Average review score:
No reviews found.
Ecrire La société féodale : lettres à Henri Berr, 1924-1943
Published in Unknown Binding by IMEC ()
Amazon base price: $
Average review score:
No reviews found.
Ein Historiker im 20. Jahrhundert : Marc Bloch
Published in Unknown Binding by S. Fischer ()
Amazon base price: $
Average review score:
No reviews found.
Histoire et historiens
Published in Unknown Binding by A. Colin ()
Amazon base price: $
Average review score:
No reviews found.
Il manoscritto interrotto di Marc Bloch : Apologia della storia e Mestiere di storico
Published in Unknown Binding by Istituti editoriali e poligrafici internazionali ()
Amazon base price: $
Average review score:
No reviews found.
The Ile-de-France: the country around Paris
Published in Unknown Binding by Routledge and K. Paul ()
Amazon base price: $
Average review score:
No reviews found.
Istoricheskii sintez i Shkola "Annalov"
Published in Unknown Binding by Izd-vo "Indrik" ()
Amazon base price: $
Average review score:
No reviews found.
Related Subjects: Author Index Reviews Page 1 2
Search Authors.BooksUnderReview.com
Reviews are from readers at Amazon.com. To add a review, follow the Amazon buy link above.