Used price: $0.74
Collectible price: $4.19
Buy one from zShops for: $3.99
Used price: $9.50
Collectible price: $27.25
List price: $12.95 (that's 20% off!)
Used price: $2.22
Buy one from zShops for: $4.19
I have read the book three times in the past six months, and will likely begin reading #4 very shortly.
Thank you Mr. Caidin.
List price: $14.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $0.74
Collectible price: $6.95
Buy one from zShops for: $1.75
Liss, currently getting a doctorate in 17th century English literature (it seems safe to say, given how well his first novel has been received, that he is probably the happiest English lit student in the country), knows his material very well, and writes with confidence and humor. He deploys some admirable literary tricks, for instance casting the novel as a memoir written decades later by Weaver, which allows him to lard in relevant and interesting historical details without too much sense of authorial intrusion. (Other successful historical novels, e.g. _The Name of the Rose_ and _Lempriere's Dictionary_ pull this trick off with geographical distance, rather than temporal, by sending their characters on journeys into unfamiliar and interesting locales.) Liss also borrows from the writing style of the novels of the time, his own stock in trade, to give the narrative a pleasantly "antiqued" diction and pace.
So what holds this novel back from the greatness to which it aspires? That most important aspect of fiction, plot. The intrigues into which Weaver are drawn, involving his father's suspicious death, stock fraud and the London criminal underground, are a bit too convoluted. It's enjoyable to watch Weaver solve the mystery, with a combination of induction (Weaver's entertaining sidekick, a penniless but charming physician, introduces him to the then-new concept of probabilistic reasoning, and draws a comparison between stock-brokering, detective work and Pascal's wager) and physical violence, but it's easy to lose track of his clues and suspicions. Liss puts so much work into the convoluted mystery that it becomes a bit exhausting. About halfway through, I found myself getting bored with all the characters and their possible motives, and all the talking and thinking about them, and looking forward to another exchange of pistols or another chase through a waste-strewn alleyway.
It's worth comparing _A Conspiracy of Paper_ to _The Name of the Rose_, the apotheosis of the historical thriller. When the truth came out in the climax of the latter book, it all made sense -- I could think back over what I'd read and see all the mysteries illuminated in the light of the truth. When finishing A Conspiracy of Paper, I was happy to find all the accumulated implausibilities and unlikelihoods neatly wrapped up, but the core of the mystery had been somewhat lost beneath the coat of loose ends.
I enjoyed reading about Jewish characters in 1700s England. Honestly I'd never considered that there was any significant Jewish community in London at that time, and it was interesting to learn about some of the restrictions on their way of life (not allowed to own property, treated as 2nd class citizens, etc.) and to read about the protagonist Ben Weaver's struggle to fit into traditional British society and to reconcile that with his Jewish roots. It was also interesting, at least in theory, to read about early stock market scandals, particularly since more sophisticated market scams (Enron, ImClone, etc.) have been big news over the last few years.
That said, as a mystery "A Conspiracy of Paper" is pretty ho-hum. Liss barely scratches the surface of London's stock exchange, instead painting the conspiracy in the broadest of strokes. "A Conspiracy of Paper" is guilty of one of my biggest book pet peeves: The mystery isn't properly foreshadowed or woven into the plot, so it comes off somewhat coincidental and left this reader flat. Weaver's true enemy really could have been a half dozen other characters in the book, all of whom would have been at least as credible as the villain. And, I found Ben Weaver to be a pretty simple, bland and generic protagonist for this kind of books. A skilled "thief-taker" (i.e. bounty hunter), boxer, good looking, fairly successful, etc.
For a quick read or summertime beach book, you could do a lot worse than "A Conspiracy of Paper," but in all it was a pretty routine and by-the-numbers mystery dressed up in Judaism and 1700s London garb.
The hero, Ben Weaver, begins to investigate the death of his long-estranged father. Soon enough he finds himself in way over his head, embroiled in the financial intrigue that would ultimately become the South Sea Bubble, causing the ruin of many of London's finest gentlemen.
The style of writing is wonderful, part first person, part narrative, and heavy into the vernacular of early 18th century England. Near the end of the story, this becomes one of those "must stay up until I finish it" books.
A thoroughly enjoyable book. I highly recommend it to those who love the genre.
Used price: $11.40
Collectible price: $17.50
List price: $12.95 (that's 20% off!)
Used price: $1.37
Collectible price: $7.41
Buy one from zShops for: $3.99
List price: $15.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $4.68
Buy one from zShops for: $6.00
and their validity is highly suspect. He uses other versions of the Bible to support his position, and roughly 150 books which he eviscerated passages to support his positions. A fairytale!
This time out Kirsch looks at the biblical figure of King David. He examines what we know of a man who is in many ways the key figure of the Bible. For those of us focused mainly on the New Testament, we need to be reminded that David was the pinnacle of Jewish success and the cornerstone of Messianic thought. It is no coincidence that Matthew and Luke are careful to trace the genealogy of Jesus through David. And Kirsch makes a very interesting case that it is possible that the books that carry the story of David (1 & 2 Samuel) may be among the oldest in the Bible around which even much of the Torah may have had its development.
Certainly, Kirsch reminds us of how very human David is. He is a virile youth and a successful warrior both for and against his countrymen. He is an anointed shepherd who takes years to secure a kingdom which he eventually must defend against his own sons. He is a servant of Yahweh who breaks nearly all the commandments at one time or another but repents. He is a believer but is steeped in pagan ritual and tradition who ultimately is not allowed to build a temple to his God. In the oldest stories, David gives us a glimpse of a people and religion that is trying to make itself into the Judaism we recognize but is still finding its way despite Abraham and Moses.
Ultimately, Kirsch leads us to an understanding of David and his time by fleshing out details and offering explanations for things that get short shrift in the Biblical text. Whether or not you accept all of Kirsch's possibilities, this book is a valuable resource for anyone who wants a clearer picture of the Old Testament world.
Used price: $75.00
Buy one from zShops for: $120.92
Used price: $0.28
Collectible price: $6.50
Buy one from zShops for: $1.99