Used price: $17.99
Used price: $0.45
Buy one from zShops for: $3.79
This first volume in "The Road to Avonlea" series is based on the Sullivan Films Production written by Heather Conkie, which, in turn, was adapted from the novels of Lucy Maud Montgomery. "The Story Girl" was Montgomery's favorite novel and its sequel "The Golden Road," along with two collections of short stories known as the Chronicles of Avonlea, are the material from which various episodes are developed.
What becomes fascinating in this first episode is how the premises of "The Story Girl" are redeveloped for this series. In the books Sara would come to visit her King cousins each summer, heading back to Montreal in the fall. However, the situation needed to be altered so Sara was a more permanent part of the Avonlea community. They could have made Sara an orphan, in the grand tradition of Montgomery's most famous literary creations Anne of Green Gables and Emily of New Moon, but it is important that at least on some level Sara WANTS to stay on PEI. At the heart is one of Montgomery's strongest themes, how a young girl forges bonds of affection with a spinster. Aunts Hetty and Olivia certainly recall Emily's Aunts Elizabeth and Laura and there are strong echoes of that novel in this story.
Consequently, whether you are a long time reader of Montgomery's works eager to devour new tales using her literary creations, or a young reader who is working their way through these books and then on to the one actually written by Montgomery, you will find these tales to be kindred spirits. I used to have the Disney Channel just so I could watch "Avonlea" and honeymooned last year on PEI, staying at the "White Sands Hotel." So, it is pretty clear that I am just one of countless millions of enraptured fans.
Used price: $0.75
Historical figures and events are portrayed with such inaccuracy that they're scarcely recognizable. To name only two examples, Governor Miles Macdonell of Assiniboia is characterized as a down-to-earth frontiersman when in reality he was a pigheaded snob, while the account of the Battle of Queenston Heights is peppered with such errors as General Brock's death being an insignificant, unlamented incident and his aide Lt. Col. Macdonell leading an "'Indian style'" attack against the Americans instead of another frontal assault, and overall, betrays a spectacular misunderstanding on the authors' part of Napoleonic-era warfare (the "absurd formality" they so disparage made perfect sense given the inaccurate muskets that were the main weapon of both British and American infantrymen. These weapons were only effective when tightly-packed formations of soldiers fired volleys at other tightly-packed formations of soldiers).
The authors display an equal ignorance of the society of that time. The characters do not think or act as people of their positions would have. The wife of a wealthy merchant in the Niagara region--whose leading citizens enjoyed a relative ly polished existence even at that early stage--is content to slave away at menial household chores and be a slave to the public in her husband's store. And, despite having run off into the wilderness with a notorious rake when she was only sixteen, she is a highly respected woman. Her son, though a commissioned army officer and supposedly sophisticated, shares her humble tastes and lack of propriety--he eschews servants and luxuries, tells ribald jokes in front of the girl he intends to marry (who would not even have been considered an acceptable wife for one of his standing), and jumps into bed with her BEFORE their wedding.
The authors provide very little information about diet, costume, and other aspects of everyday life, and this information is often incorrect. Charac- ters eat fresh corn-on-the-cob in November. A middle-aged matron wears her hair pulled back in a ponytail, while another female character wears hers down long. A young officer wears neither hat, sash, cravat, nor sword, his "uniform" consisting of "pants", "heavy shirt, jacket, and boots". He and his fellow officers at Fort George are crowded together in a barracks and sleep on the same uncomfortable bunks as are used by their men, instead of having well-appointed private quarters.
WILDFIRES does not even have the saving grace of being an entertaining read. The characters are strictly 2-D, and their impossibly convoluted ad- ventures are interrupted by tedious textbook-style history lessons and related in the lamest of prose.
Used price: $0.75
Collectible price: $2.12
Used price: $16.51
Used price: $6.99
Used price: $1.85
Collectible price: $7.29